CO129-160 - Public Offices - 1872 — Page 75

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

10%.

74

The case to which I will refer is that of the Athol reported by M. Robinson's in the first volume of Reports p. 374, in which the late learned Judge of the Court of Admiralty Dr. Kuchington refused to decree a monition against the Lords of the Admiralty in respect of damage done to the English Ship Athol by Her Majesty's Ships. One of the principal grounds on which the learned Judge refused the monition was because he observed that the Court would have no power to enforce the monition should the Lords of the Admiralty refuse to obey it. At the same time he stated, quoting Lord Stowell in the Case of the "Mentor", that the actual wearer was the proper person to commence judgment; and that a libel ought therefore to be issued against the Captain of the Queen's Ships.

One more case shall be...

Edit History

2026-05-20 21:43:41 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
10%. 74 The case to which I will refer is that of the Athol reported by M. Robinson's in the first volume of Reports p. 374, in which the late learned Judge of the Court of Admiralty Dr. Kuchington refused to decree a monition against the Lords of the Admiralty in respect of damage done to the English Ship Athol by Her Majesty's Ships. One of the principal grounds on which the learned Judge refused the monition was because he observed that the Court would have no power to enforce the monition should the Lords of the Admiralty refuse to obey it. At the same time he stated, quoting Lord Stowell in the Case of the "Mentor", that the actual wearer was the proper person to commence judgment; and that a libel ought therefore to be issued against the Captain of the Queen's Ships. One more case shall be...
Baseline (Original)
} 10%. 74 The auxet care to which I will that of the Athol reported M. Robinson's refer i in the first volume of Reports p. 374, in which the late learned Judge of the Court of Admiralty Dr Kuchington refused to decrde a monition against the Lords of the Ademically in respect damage done to lan English ! Drip by Her Majesty & Groups Sh Athal. One of the principal grounds "load re 2 refused the monition in hich the more mas, the learned) Judge observed, because the would have no power to enforce the monition Chould if the Cords of the Admiralty child to a by it. At the same refuse time be statibl. stated, quo quoting Lord Stowell the the words Case of. doer Mentor, that the actual wearer. was the proper person to Canemer juoyment; and that & Position ought therefore to iene aganist the Captain of the Proops Phips. litid on One More Cave shall be > this point, it is that of B
2026-05-20 21:43:41 · Baseline
View content

}

10%.

74

The auxet care to which I will

that of the Athol reported M. Robinson's

refer

i

in the first volume of Reports p. 374, in which the late learned Judge of the Court of Admiralty Dr Kuchington refused to decrde a monition against

the Lords of the Ademically in respect

damage

done to lan

English

! Drip by Her Majesty & Groups Sh Athal. One of the principal

grounds

"load re

2

refused

the monition in hich the more

mas,

the learned)

Judge observed, because the would have no power to enforce

the monition

Chould

if the Cords of the Admiralty child

to

a by

it. At the same

refuse

time be statibl.

stated, quo

quoting

Lord Stowell

the

the words

Case

of.

doer

Mentor, that the actual wearer.

was the proper person to Canemer juoyment; and that & Position ought therefore to iene aganist

the Captain of the Proops Phips. –

litid on

One

More

Cave

shall be

>

this point, it is that of

B

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.